November 03, 2016
Kevin C. Shelly, File/PhillyVoice
Eight-year-old Gabby Hill-Carter was shot while riding her bike in front of her family's home in the 900 block of South Ninth Street in the Bergen Square neighborhood of Camden. She died two days later from her injuries.
There were witnesses when Gabby Hill-Carter, an 8-year-old playing in the street in front of her South Ninth Street home in Camden, was struck by an errant bullet during a gang shooting.
But they have yet to confide in police to the extent that cops have been able make additional arrests two months later.
Even though the young girl was an innocent, talking to authorities about her killers is considered snitching, a pervasive problem in urban law enforcement.
According to authorities, Tyhan Brown, 18, accompanied by several other young men, was quite literally gunning for Amir Dixon on Aug. 24.
That’s when authorities say Brown allegedly fired a shot that hit Hill-Carter; she died two days later. Police were fairly sure of his involvement from the start. He's charged with first-degree murder in Hill-Carter's death. He's held on $1.5 million bail in the Camden County jail.
But finding somebody to finger Brown and his confederates was another issue, despite a record $76,000 reward that remains unclaimed.
As Scott Thomson, chief of the Camden police department, said when the Brown arrest was announced, "we did not receive the support we had hoped for" with information from tipsters.
Tyhan Brown, 18, of the 1800 block of Kossuth Street in Camden, is charged with first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of 8-year-old Gabby Hill-Carter, authorities said.
Police have even charged Brown’s mother, Shakia Land, and girlfriend, Natasha Gerald, with providing false alibis.
Brown was finally arrested about a month after the incident, picked up at family member’s home in Tennessee.
He's charged with firing the shot that killed Hill-Carter, held on $1.5 million bail in the Camden County jail.
At the time of Brown’s arrest, Camden City Council President Frank Moran said he was confident that capturing Brown and charging him meant authorities would find and arrest those involved in committing murder in the city.
“Those who know ain’t sayin’. And those who are sayin’ don’t know.” – Resident of Hill-Carter’s Bergen Square neighborhood
But that has not happened: several others suspected of stalking Dixon along with Brown remain at large.
And ironically, it is just part of a cycle: Brown’s own father was murdered in Camden in 2012, a case that was never solved.
“Those who know ain’t sayin’. And those who are sayin’ don’t know,” said a resident of Hill-Carter’s Bergen Square neighborhood, who asked to remain anonymous as she talked Saturday morning about the names and whereabouts of Brown’s alleged accomplices.
Just last week, the city recorded two homicides in fewer than 24 hours, bringing the number of murders this year to 37. Both recent murders remain unsolved.
Solving homicides is an issue in all urban areas and is often attributable to a lack of cooperation and a fear of retribution among the community.
Camden’s solve rate on murders in recent years has bounced around from as high as 60 percent to as low as the upper 30 percent range. At the end of October, the solve rate stood at 61 percent.
Gabby Hill Carter, 8, was killed by a stray bullet as she played outside in her neighborhood.
Tasha Mack Thorton/Contributed photo
Jon M. Shane, a former Newark police captain, former member of a special study commission which examined the Camden police force, said solve rates are related to a pervasive code of silence in inner cities – often summed up as “Stop snitching.”
“It is so stinking hard to overcome,” said Shane, a professor of criminology at John Jay College in New York.
The report he helped author about Camden in 2006 summarizes the issue:
“Because the police department is the only agency on the streets of the city 24 hours a day, handling a wide range of complex problems, the police come to represent the 'government' to many citizens.
“Often then, communities unfairly view police as responsible for conditions that the agency has neither the resources nor the authority to address.”
“Promises get made, but then witnesses get burned. Witnesses even get gunned down. There’s no social benefit [in cooperating]." – John Shane, former Newark police captain
According to Shane, it's a cultural problem.
"Residents identify more with their ethnic group, their neighborhood, than with the city. And it is a us-against-them perspective,” he said. “It’s the code of the street, part of the lifestyle and culture” of drug gangs.
But Shane said that "say nothing" attitude has spread because so many people in a city like Camden have had “negative interactions” not just with police, but also with city government.
He said a child forced to walk down the streets of Camden, surrounded by “genuine poverty,” past abandoned buildings and then attend “s***ty schools,” cannot help but develop a negative attitude, “with nothing to look forward to.”
That’s been the case in Camden for 50 years, he said.
In many cases, the community skepticism has little to do with police, he said, though adding that the criminal justice system is seen as “self-serving.”
“Promises get made, but then witnesses get burned. Witnesses even get gunned down. There’s no social benefit” in cooperating, Shane said.
“It will take decades [for police] to rebuild confidence” in the community, Shane said.
On the police end of solving murders in a city with the issues Camden shares with other far larger urban areas is a “practical reality.”
“You know if you are working homicide, another shooting is coming,” meaning cops may see a case where an alleged shooter is in custody as wrapped up even if confederates remain at large, Shane said.
A memorial for Gabby Hill-Carter, photographed days after her murder.
Kevin C. Shelly, File/PhillyVoice
Susan Clampet-Lundquist, a St. Joseph’s University professor of sociology who co-authored a paper on snitching last year, said small neighborhoods amplify the problem.
In a place like Camden, filled with neighborhood alliances, “the person selling drugs is a relative or someone you grew up with,” making the message to not talk to authorities all the stronger, she said.
Snitching is an issue that once applied only to those “in the game,” but it has become more expansive, she said.
Thomson, who has been police chief in Camden since 2008, said, “The 'stop snitching' culture is not a new social phenomenon and has been a concern in our country for quite a long time.”
He understands why the no-snitching message is compelling and admits that social media has made fighting that message all the more difficult because identities can be discovered and spread quite easily.
“When you truly understand the dynamic of most challenged communities, coupled with the protections of the accused within our country’s criminal justice system, people often avoid involvement as a deliberate decision for the safety of their families and themselves," Thomson said.
“Who has the resources or options of relocating or abandoning their own support systems? It is frustrating for us as law enforcement when we are trying to make an arrest, but I empathize with people’s fears and their concerns are real.
“I would like to see changes to our system that could better protect the identities of people who are courageous enough to cooperate.”
